Every Saturday morning from April through October, Glenn loads the 2017 Subaru Outback while I stand at the kitchen counter making sandwiches. Two folding chairs, one tarp, a dog bed that Juniper ignores, and lunch for a day that starts at a state park and ends whenever the light goes. On Friday nights the Igloo Trailmate sits by the back door, already packed, waiting to be carried out. That cooler is the only piece of camping gear I have ever replaced and then stopped thinking about, which for me is the highest compliment I can pay a thing I own.

For six years before that, Saturday lunch was a disappointment I kept scheduling. The old cooler was a hand-me-down with a lid that never quite seated. I would pack turkey sandwiches at seven in the morning, and by noon I would open it and find them sitting in an inch of water. Not damp. Floating. Glenn would fish one out, hold it over the gravel, and say something generous about how bread tastes fine when it is wet.

A person reaching into an open hard-sided cooler sitting on a car tailgate at a campsite.

I tried the usual fixes first. A second, smaller cooler just for food, which meant two coolers to carry and two coolers to drain. Freezer packs wrapped in dish towels. A plastic container inside the big cooler, which worked until it tipped on the drive in. Zipper bags, which I dislike, because I sew and I know what a zipper is being asked to do when it has to hold back water for six hours.

What finally changed my mind was not a review or a recommendation. It was noticing that the mess was never the ice. The mess was the lid. A cooler that does not seal does not keep anything, and no amount of rearranging the contents fixes that. So I went looking for a hard shell with an insulated lid that seated properly, and the Trailmate is what I came home with.

The Igloo numbers, since I am the sort of person who writes them on an index card: 50 quarts, 15.4 pounds empty, 18 inches deep by 25.7 wide by 16.7 tall. It holds 81 cans, which is Glenn's unit of measurement for everything. The walls are 1.5 inch foam and the lid is insulated, and there is a design detail called Cool Riser Technology that lifts the body away from hot surfaces. It sits in the back of the Outback with the dog bed wedged beside it, which is the only fit test that matters in our house.

By Sunday afternoon there was still ice in it, and I had not thought about the cooler once all weekend.

No more sandwiches in an inch of water

50 quarts, 15.4 pounds empty, and an insulated lid that actually seats. If your Saturday lunch keeps ending up wet, start here.

Check Today's Price on Amazon →

The first weekend we took it out was a two-night stay at a state park outside Shelton. I packed it Friday evening with two bags of ice, a dozen cans, a quart of potato salad, and the sandwiches. Saturday at noon I opened it and the ice was still mostly ice. Sunday morning, same. Sunday afternoon I poured off what had melted and it was a couple of inches in the bottom, which is what a cooler is supposed to do and what our old one had never once done.

Two people eating lunch at a picnic table with a cooler on the ground and a dog resting underneath.

The handles deserve their own paragraph, because I have carried coolers by bad handles and I know how that ends. These are extra wide, with a reinforced crossbar and a diamond textured grip, so a full cooler does not cut into your fingers on the walk from the car to the table. Empty it weighs 15.4 pounds and I can move it myself. Full of ice and cans it weighs considerably more, and Glenn carries it. I want to be honest about that. It is not a light cooler once you have filled it.

Juniper is 42 pounds of cattle dog mix with claws, and she treats anything on the ground as furniture. She has stood on the lid. She has scrambled past it getting out of the car. A hard shell takes that in a way our old lid never did, and it wipes clean with a rag and a little dish soap at the end of the weekend. The lid still seats properly after two seasons of this, which sounds like a small thing until you have spent six years with one that did not.

What it is not: it is not small. At 25.7 inches wide and 16.7 tall it takes up real floor space in the back of the Outback, and on the one longer trip a year, when the bigger tent comes along, something else stays home. It is also heavier and more awkward to lift than a soft-sided bag. If you are carrying a cooler any real distance to a walk-in site, or packing one into a canoe, this is the wrong shape of thing. We do neither. We drive to a site, park, and eat.

What I'd Tell You If We Were Sitting at My Kitchen Table

If you were across from me with a cup of coffee, here is what I would say. The cooler is not the part of camping anyone talks about, but it is the part you touch twice a day, and a bad one quietly ruins lunch for years before you admit it. I spent six summers working around a cooler instead of replacing it, which was stubbornness dressed up as thrift. What I would tell you to check, in order: does the lid seat, do the walls feel thick when you knock on them, and can you carry it full without a handle biting your hand. The Igloo Trailmate does all three. It is 50 quarts, it is 15.4 pounds empty, and it holds 81 cans, which in our house means a weekend for four people with room left for the potato salad. Then stop thinking about it and go sit down. That is the whole advice.

Packed Friday night, still cold Sunday afternoon

The Igloo Trailmate is a 50 quart hard shell cooler with 1.5 inch foam insulated walls, an insulated lid, and extra wide side handles with a diamond textured grip. Rated 4.6 stars across 643 reviews.

Check Today's Price on Amazon →