I have owned a director chair for years. It is the folding kind with the canvas seat, and it looks like something a person with taste would carry to a campsite. What it does not have is a place to put a drink. Last June, at a state park outside Shelton, my husband Glenn set his coffee on the ground beside his director chair, forgot it was there, and stood up. We spent ten minutes with a roll of paper towels and another five talking about it. On the way home I bought the Coleman Portable Camping Chair with 4-Can Cooler, mostly out of spite.

That is the comparison in one story, but it is not the whole comparison. A director chair is the better piece of furniture. The Coleman chair is the better camping chair for the way we actually camp, which is drive-in sites, a cooler in the back of a 2017 Subaru Outback, a dog who will not stay off anything she fits on, and an evening that starts at five and ends when the fire dies. I have packed and unpacked that car close to a hundred times now, and I have opinions about which chair earns its floor space.

My short answer: if you sit for an hour or two and want a cold drink within reach without dragging a side table along, buy the Coleman. If you sit for four hours with a book and have trouble standing up out of a low seat, buy a director chair. If your knees have started to have opinions, read the seat height row in the table below twice before you decide, because that row is the whole argument.

One note on who this is for. If you walk in to a site with a pack on your back, neither of these belongs there. This is for the drive-in camper, the state park weekend, the person who unloads the car once and stays put for two days. That is most of us at this age, and it is the frame I am comparing them in.

Coleman Camping ChairA Director Chair
Getting in and outSeat sits low, so standing up takes a rock forward and a push off the armsTaller seat, closer to dining chair height, easier on stiff knees
Drink and snack storageFour-can cooler built into the arm, plus a mesh cup holder and side pocketsNothing built in, so the cup goes on the ground or on a table you brought
CushioningCushioned seat, solid back, cushioned head restCanvas sling, no padding anywhere
Folded shapeFolds into a long bundle that has to lie down in the carFolds flat and stands on its own, tucks behind a seat
Stated weight3.5 kg, about 7.7 pounds, per the listingVaries by model, and the ones I have lifted run heavier
Seat and capacity24-inch seat, listed to hold up to 325 poundsNarrower canvas seat, and the ratings vary by maker
WarrantyThe listing states no manufacturer warrantyVaries by brand, and I have never filed a claim on either
Best forLong evenings where you want a cold drink at your elbowSitting upright to read, write, or play cards
Life with a muddy dogFabric wipes down, but the cooler compartment catches gritCanvas stains and the folding joints collect mud

How I Compared Them

Five things, because those are the five things that decide it at a drive-in site. How easy the chair is to get in and out of, which matters more every year. Where the drink goes. How it feels on the second hour, not the first. How it folds and how much floor space it takes in a car that already has a dog and a cooler in it. And how it stands up to weather, mud, and a 42-pound dog who treats every flat surface as hers.

I am not going to pretend this is a lab test. It is two chairs, one car, three seasons of weekends, and the habit of looking at seams that comes from sewing gear repairs all winter. Where a number exists, I used the number from the listing. Where it does not, I said so, which is why a few rows in that table end in a tie.

A hand lifting a can out of the cooler compartment built into the arm of a folding camping chair, a camp table and a mug blurred in the background

Where the Coleman Chair Wins

Storage is the reason this chair exists. The arm holds a four-can cooler, which puts the drinks you are actually going to finish inches from your hand instead of in the big cooler behind your chair. There is a mesh cup holder for whatever you are holding right now, plus side pockets for the small things that otherwise end up in the dirt: the phone, the headlamp, the end of the leash. The listing also gives a cushioned head rest and a solid back, and the seat is 24 inches wide.

It is listed to hold up to 325 pounds, and I do not feel the frame move under me when I sit down. Glenn is 61 and heavier than I am and says the same. The seat has some give to it, so a long evening in it does not end with a sore tailbone, which is more than I can say for a canvas sling after the same three hours.

The weight and size are worth knowing before you buy. The listing gives 3.5 kg, which is about 7.7 pounds, and 40.5 inches deep by 24 inches wide by 37 inches tall. Folded, it is a long bundle shaped roughly like a bag chair, so it lies down in the well behind the back seat with the dog's bed on top of it. It is not a chair you would carry a mile to a walk-in site. At a drive-in site the carry does not matter and the cooler within reach does.

In practice the cooler holds four cans, which covers the hour before dinner and not the whole evening. It is not a replacement for the big cooler on the tailgate. It is the difference between a cold drink and a warm one when you have already sat down and the fire is finally catching.

In August we spent a week at a site on the Olympic Peninsula with one picnic table between four people. The pattern that emerged was simple: Glenn filled the four cans before dinner, set the chair where he wanted it, and the chair did the rest. Nobody had to get up mid-conversation, nothing got knocked off the table, and the only thing on the ground all week was the dog bowl. By the fourth night the guests had claimed the Coleman and I was the one in the canvas chair, which tells you something about which seat people gravitate to.

Where a Director Chair Wins

Height, and it is not close. A director chair puts the seat nearer knee height. You sit down into it the way you sit into a dining chair, and you stand up out of it the same way. On a damp morning my hip is stiff and I can get out of the director chair without using my arms at all. Getting out of the Coleman takes a rock forward and a push off the armrests. If you have had a knee replaced, that difference is worth more than a cooler, and I would not argue with you about it.

Take one morning in mid-September, forty-one degrees, everything damp and nothing dry enough to sit on without thinking about it. Glenn was out of his director chair and standing over the stove before I had finished pushing off the armrests of mine. By the time I was upright he had coffee going and had already made a remark about it. Nothing dramatic. Just a small daily tax, paid in the cold, at an hour when you would rather not pay anything.

Folding. A director chair folds flat and stands up on its own, against the garage wall or on the floor behind the front seat. The Coleman folds into a bundle that has to lie down and has to be shoved. We keep two chairs in the car from April to October, and the director chair is the one that does not start an argument about space.

Posture and looks. The director chair back is upright, which is what you want if you read, write, or play cards at the picnic table. The Coleman is a lounging chair by comparison, built for looking at a fire with your legs out. The director chair also reads as furniture, which is why it ends up on the porch when the season is over while the Coleman goes back in the garage.

The chair that keeps the drinks out of the dirt

Coleman Portable Camping Chair with 4-Can Cooler: a 24-inch seat, a four-can cooler built into the arm, a mesh cup holder, side pockets, a cushioned head rest, listed to hold up to 325 pounds. Fold it, drop it behind the seat, and stop balancing your coffee on your knee.

Check Today's Price on Amazon →

The Dog, the Mud, and the Seams

I sew gear repairs in the winter, so I look at stitching the way other people look at scenery. On the Coleman, the fabric is bound at the front rail, and that rail is where a chair like this wears out first. On a canvas director chair, the panel is pinned to the frame and the corners take the strain. Both collect dog hair at the same rate. Neither is a dog bed, though Juniper has decided otherwise about the director chair, and the mud she brings back from the creek goes straight into the canvas and stays there until I scrub it.

Winter repairs are where I learn what a chair is actually made of. I went over both of them in January, not far, just enough to look at the wear spots with a lamp and a seam ripper on the worktable. The Coleman had rubbed at the top of the front rail where the seat meets the frame, and the binding there had gone slightly fuzzy. The director chair had gone soft at the corners of the canvas panel where it wraps the pins. Neither one is failing. Both are showing me where they will fail first, and knowing that is how you get six seasons out of a chair instead of three.

The side pockets on the Coleman are the feature I did not expect to use. Leash end, headlamp, a roll of bags. On the director chair all of that lives on the ground, which is fine until it rains, and then it is not fine at all.

Getting out of the Coleman takes a rock forward and a push off the armrests. Getting out of the director chair takes nothing. That is the whole trade, and only you know which side of it you are on.
A tall folding director chair with a canvas seat standing beside a camp table at dusk, a paperback book and a lantern on the table, treeline behind

What Neither Chair Solves

Neither one has a side table. The Coleman's cooler holds four cans, which is the drinks you are drinking now, not the whole weekend. The director chairs I have sat in have no cup holder at all, so with one of those a small table is not optional. Neither chair is a bench for two, neither will do anything about a cold wind, and neither is light enough to be worth carrying any distance. If you want the longer argument for cold storage built into a chair, it is in 10 reasons a camping chair with a cooler is worth it.

And neither will last forever in the back of a car. Both want a wipe down and a dry spell in the garage at the end of the season. The Coleman listing states no manufacturer warranty, so treat it like something you plan to look after rather than something you plan to replace.

Who Should Skip Both

Skip both if what you want is a chair with a table attached, a rocker, or something that packs into a stuff sack for a walk-in site. A plain bag chair with a folding side table is a different answer to a different question, and it is not a wrong one. Skip both, too, if you only sit for twenty minutes at a stretch and you are happy enough on the cooler lid.

Who Should Buy Which

Buy the Coleman if your camping looks like ours. A drive-in site, a fire, an evening that runs long, and a drink you want within arm's reach without getting up. It is also the chair I hand to guests, because the 24-inch seat and the 325-pound rating mean I do not have to think about who is sitting in it. For two chairs that live in the car all season, this is the one I would buy first. There is a longer wear report in the Coleman camping chair long-term review if you want to know how it has held up.

One more piece of arithmetic before you decide. Two Colemans and a dog bed fill the back of the Outback with nothing left over. One Coleman and one director chair leaves room for the duffel and the folding table. If you are packing for two people and a dog every weekend from April to October, that floor space matters more than any single line on the table above, and it is the reason we did not end up with a matched pair of either.

Buy a director chair if you sit longer than you lounge, if you read or do handwork at the table, or if standing up out of a low seat has turned into a project. They are also the chairs that look right on a porch or at a craft fair, which is not nothing. Glenn still brings his and I have stopped arguing about it. We each have the chair we will actually sit in, and honestly, that is the whole decision.

Start with the chair you will actually sit in

A 24-inch seat, a four-can cooler in the arm, a mesh cup holder, side pockets and a cushioned head rest. 3.5 kg, listed to 325 pounds, and it folds into the well behind the back seat. This is the one that ends the balancing act.

Check Today's Price on Amazon →